160,000+ Books, Games & Puzzles in-stock 🇳🇿 

Happy Halloween!  Our Hobsonville Bookstore is open today for spooky fun and sweet treats! 🎃

Witchful Thinking

By Celestine Martin
0.0 (0 reviews)
3.43 goodreads logo

Ratings/reviews counts are updated frequently.

Check link for latest rating. ( 3,707 ratings, 889 reviews)
Book Hero Magic crafted this summary to help describe this book. While it's new and still learning, it may not be perfect - your feedback is welcome! Summary
Witchful Thinking follows witch Lucy Caraway, who, bored with life's monotony, casts a mystical spell that brings back her high school crush, merman Alex Dwyer. Alex, newly landed with a jinxed cottage in their small hometown, returns with plans to move on, but the rekindled connection with Lucy makes him reconsider. Amid magical mishaps, flirtatious moments, and rediscovered chemistry, they explore whether love sparked by a wish can endure beyond its fleeting magic.
Read More
Format: Paperback / softback
$5300

International Supplier

This title is in-stock with overseas suppliers. While it is not available locally, we fly books in weekly from the US and UK to our Auckland warehouse for immediate dispatch.

AVAILABLE WITH SUPPLIER Ships from our Auckland warehouse within 2-3 weeks

Found a better price? Request a price match

Book Hero Magic created this recommendation. While it's new and still learning, it may not be perfect - your feedback is welcome! IS THIS YOUR NEXT READ?

Ideal for readers who enjoy lighthearted paranormal romance featuring witches and merfolk, with themes of nostalgia, magic, and rekindled love. Lovers of character-driven stories with a cosy small-town setting will also find much to enjoy.

Book Hero thinking about your next read

A family of witches, a small-town shrouded in magic, and an opposites-attract romance will keep readers turning the pages of this delightful witchy rom-com debut.

Book Hero Magic formatted this description to make it easier to read. While it's new and still learning, it may not be perfect - your feedback is welcome! Description

What does a witch do when life's a bore? You wish for something more.

If wishes were fish, homebody witch Lucy Caraway could open an aquarium and gift shop. When she isn't grading papers over homemade tea blends, Lucy’s leafing through spellbooks to protect her familial magic from complete mayhem. On the eve of her ten-year high school reunion, Lucy yearns for more: the soul mate she's searching for, the cute cottage she's coveting, and to be the best version of herself. Fueled by nostalgia and spiced rum, Lucy casts a spell that brings trouble in the form of a big lie and reunites her with her high school crush, merman Alex Dwyer.

Like all merfolk, Alex saw the world and all its splendours, destined never to make a home on land. When he's unexpectedly given a jinxed cottage, he returns to his small hometown of Freya Grove, NJ, determined to get his life on track after a string of bitter disappointments. Alex believes a merman needs a house like a fish needs a bicycle. He plans on flipping it and getting as far away from the Grove as his tail can take him. But once he discovers that his new neighbour is the witch who got away, Alex starts to rethink his plan.

As the spell unfolds, baking disasters, flirtatious tea readings, and midnight meetups spark their decade-old chemistry. Lucy and Alex wonder whether their newfound love is strong enough to outlast the fleeting power of a wish.

Witchful Thinking is a whimsical tale of magic, love, and the unexpected twists of fate.

Book Hero Magic summarised reviews for this book. While it's new and still learning, it may not be perfect - your feedback is welcome! HOW HAS THIS BEEN REVIEWED?

Acclaimed as a sparkling debut full of literal Black Girl Magic by Adriana Herrera, this charming paranormal romance has been praised by Library Journal for making readers want to stay and fall in love. Publishers Weekly highlights Martin as an author to watch, while April Asher commends the novel's spellbinding blend of magic, second chances, and risk-taking in love.

Book Hero reading reviews

Book Details

INFORMATION

ISBN: 9781538738078

Publisher: Little, Brown & Company

Format: Paperback / softback

Date Published: 08 December 2022

Country: United States

Imprint: Forever

Audience: General / adult

DIMENSIONS

Spine width: 24.0mm

Width: 132.0mm

Height: 202.0mm

Weight: 300g

Pages: 352

Collections

Celestine Martin Contemporary Romance Fiction General Fiction Health & Wellness Paranormal Romance Romance Self-Help & Personal Development

About the Author

A native of New Jersey, Celestine Martin writes whimsical romance that celebrates the beauty of everyday magic. She's inspired to write happily ever afters and happy-for-now endings starring the people and places close to her heart. When she's not drinking herbal tea and researching her next project, Celestine, with her husband, spoils their daughter in New York on a daily basis. You can find her on social media @JellybeanRae on Twitter, @CelestineMartinWrites on Instagram, or check in on her at CelestineMartin.com.

More from Romance

View all
  • Grim Tidings
    New Release
    Grim Tidings
    'Infinity stars. I smiled, laughed, squealed with delight, wept, and then smiled again' ★★★★★'This book ripped my heart out, trampled on it, put it back together, and still had amazing smut' ★★★★★'Fun, witty, sexy and made me cry at the end (in a good way, don't worry)…B.K. Borison has written one of my favourite reads of the year' ★★★★★ A...
    By B.K. Borison
    Paperback
    $2399
    Elsewhere:
    $2899
    (2)
    In Stock
    Ships tomorrow
  • How to Kill a Guy in Ten Dates
    How to Kill a Guy in Ten Dates
    A hilarious, swoony and downright terrifying horror romance in which a cinephile gets caught in the middle of a murder spree at a speed-dating event and must use her encyclopedic knowledge of the rom-com and horror genres to make it as a real-life Final Girl. When cinephile Jamie Prescott attends a speed-dating event, she expects to meet some mediocre men...
    By Shailee Thompson
    Paperback
    $3199
    Elsewhere:
    $3999
    (2)
    In Stock
    Ships tomorrow
  • Wild Wicked Mate
    New Release
    Wild Wicked Mate
    From #1 New York Times bestselling author Laurie Gilmore, comes a brand new small-town romance set in the quirky town of Maple Hollow! The closer the proximity, the stronger the spark… Phoebe never expected to fall in love, and especially not with the annoyingly handsome werewolf she’s been hanging out with for years.Theo has spent his life comparing himself to...
    By Laurie Gilmore
    Paperback
    $2199
    Elsewhere:
    $2699
    In Stock
    Ships tomorrow
  • New Release
    The Keeper
    He can resist any woman in the world...except for the one he shouldn't want. Famed goalkeeper Noah Wilson doesn't do relationships or complications. The only thing the grumpy single dad wants is to do his job and spend more time with his daughter. Unfortunately, his bachelor status has made it impossible to find the right nanny for her. With the...
    By Ana Huang
    Paperback
    $2400
    Elsewhere:
    $2799
    In Stock
    Ships tomorrow
  • The Song of the Sirens
    New Release
    The Song of the Sirens
    A sweeping romantasy debut about sisterhood, rebellion, and the danger of forbidden love, featuring ancient immortal clans, hidden spells, morally grey love interests, and a war that threatens to fracture the realms – for fans of Sarah J. Maas, Penn Cole and Victoria Aveyard. Exiled to the mortal realm of Asterra for a crime their mother committed, Siren sisters Adriana...
    By Taylah Walker
    Paperback
    $3199
    Elsewhere:
    $3999
    In Stock
    Ships tomorrow
  • My Dreadful Darling
    New Release
    My Dreadful Darling
    My darling, it is you who is dreadful. Reverie Adams has only one goal in life: to keep her head above water with her father's sinister legacy weighing on her shoulders. But she's no stranger to drowning—it is her very first memory, after all, and if her demons have their way, it will also be her last. Even with the...
    By H. D. Carlton
    Paperback
    $3199
    Elsewhere:
    $3800
    In Stock
    Ships tomorrow
  • Fever Dream
    From #1 New York Times bestselling author Elsie Silver comes a small-town, forbidden, rivals-to-lovers romance, the first book in the brand-new Western romance series Emerald Lake. Limited copies with sprayed edges!Professional bull rider Emmett Bush is not looking for love. He’s looking for a paycheque to save his family’s farm from bankruptcy. So when he agrees to be the leading man on...
    By Elsie Silver
    Paperback
    $2499
    Elsewhere:
    $2899
    In Stock
    Ships tomorrow
  • Midnight Curfew
    New Release
    Midnight Curfew
    The Jaeger family return in the brand new queer, dark romance from New York Times bestselling author Penelope Douglas, in which two rivals must fight their forbidden and burning attraction to one another. Summertime is quiet in southern Florida. In the humidity, the streets are empty, and the nights are still—perfect for a little mischief while the police aren't looking....
    By Penelope Douglas
    Paperback
    $2299
    Elsewhere:
    $2800
    In Stock
    Ships tomorrow
  • I Hope This Email Finds You in Hell
    New Release
    I Hope This Email Finds You in Hell
    What could go wrong on a road trip to Hell? ⭐ corporate hell vibes ⭐ only one bed ⭐ a road trip through the underworld ⭐ forced proximity ⭐ slow burn romance 'A delirious, clever romp of a book. Best time I've had with a book in ages!' JENNA LEVINE Brie Benson lives life in survival mode, right down to...
    By Mackenzie Reed
    Paperback
    $2499
    Elsewhere:
    $2799
    In Stock
    Ships tomorrow
  • New Release
    Christmas Staycation
    Christmas Staycation by Meghan Quinn: Nothing says Merry Christmas like fake fiancés, family pressure, and accidentally falling for your ex's brother... Nolan never met a spotlight he didn't like. As a major league baseball player with a filthy mouth, an ego the size of the North Pole, and zero interest in behaving, he's perfectly happy breezing into Christmas in Kringletown...
    By Meghan Quinn
    Paperback
    $2499
    Elsewhere:
    $2799
    In Stock
    Ships tomorrow
  • Psychotic Obsession
    From USA Today bestselling author and TikTok sensation comes the steamy, emotional dark romance spin-off that everyone is talking about!'Filled with TENSION, HEARTBREAK and ELECTRIC CHEMISTRY. This one will tear your heart right out of your chest before tossing it back in and sewing you up' No. 1 New York Times bestselling author Brynne Weaver'Leigh Rivers is THE QUEEN OF...
    By Leigh Rivers
    Paperback
    $2200
    Elsewhere:
    $2799
    Backorder
    Ships early November
  • A Married Little Christmas
    New Release
    A Married Little Christmas
    Step into Christmas with Abby and Maya Jimenez - a special hardback packable of swoon-worthy novellas, recipes to make and illustrations.
    By Abby Jimenez
    Paperback
    $3199
    Elsewhere:
    $3799
    In Stock
    Ships tomorrow

Why buy from us?

Book Hero is not a chain store or big box retailer. We're an independent 100% NZ-owned business on a mission to help more Kiwis rediscover a love of books and reading!

Service & Delivery

Service & Delivery

Our warehouse in Auckland holds over 160,000 books, toys, board games and puzzles in-stock so you're not waiting for your order to arrive from overseas.

Auckland Bookstore

Auckland Bookstore

We're primarily an online store, but for your convenience you can pick up your order for free from our bookstore, which is right next door to our warehouse in Hobsonville.

Our Gifting Service

Our Gifting Service

Books make wonderful thoughtful gifts and we're here to help with gift-wrapping and cards. We can even send your gift directly to your loved one.

Romance lists from the team

Explore our curated lists from our heroes to find your next read!

The Latest at Book Hero

View all